• About
  • Contact Me
  • Archive

OurCity.London

Investigative journalism into the town planning and development industries

  • Home
  • Issues
    • Financial Viability
  • Photography
  • Write for OurCity.London
  • March 3, 2021
You are here: Home / Case Studies / Lockdown Landlords Acquitted

Lockdown Landlords Acquitted

May 29, 2018 By George Turner 1 Comment

Last year, we reported on the criminal conviction of Wise Estates, Simon Low and Manlow Property Management for failing to abide by a planning enforcement notice. 

All three defendants were in the dock over the same property, 9 Stonebridge Park in Brent, a small family home that had been converted into six micro-flats. Brent claimed that the defendants had converted these flats unlawfully, as they had not obtained planning permission. The defendants had previously claimed that they did not need permission as the property was an HMO, not  a development of flats, a claim rejected by the Planning Inspectorate.

The defense from Manlow to the criminal charge of refusing to abide by the terms of a planning enforcement notice regarding the property, was that they were not in control of the home at the time, having sold their property portfolio to a social landlord, Omega Mears. At the Magistrates Court the only evidence of this was a letter in the defense bundle, and the District Judge did not see this as sufficient. 

The defendants appealed to the Crown Court. They produced new evidence, an employee of Omega Housing Association who said that they were in control of the home at the relevant time. This got Simon Low and Manlow off the charge, but Wise Estates’ conviction remains and they are now subject to a proceeds of crime order. 

The lawyer for the Low family and Wise Estates confirmed the position regarding the 9 Stonebridge Park case, but was not able to provide an on the record comment. 

However, in a subsequent email complaining about my original reporting of the case, Pincus Mann, a director of Manlow Property Management said:

I understand for you it’s just a reported story, for me the story had the potential to ruin my businesses, but don’t path yourself on your shoulder yet, it actually didn’t, 👍.

I guess this means that Manlow is still in the business of cramming tiny flats into small homes and renting them out at extortionate rents to the homeless – which is a pity, because although Manlow and Mr Low may have got off this time, the case still established that the conversion of family homes into multiple tiny flats, a model called Lockdown, requires planning permission, and councils can refuse to grant permission for these developments if they choose. From Mr Mann’s response, it would seem that some councils are still not availing themselves of the powers they have to stop this practice.

Filed Under: Case Studies, Micro-flats Tagged With: David Sonn, Lockdown, Manlow, Pincus Mann, Simon Low

Comments

  1. John says

    July 19, 2020 at 12:32 pm

    In the old days, for the cost to the council of one salary, a rent officer was employed to check the size of rooms and the services included. The benefit payable would then vary accordingly instead of being a flat rate. Returning to a sensible system involving some level of individual case assessment would avoid this blatant exploitation but the council don’t seem to care as the benefit paid out is refunded from by the DWP.

    To make things worse the VOA likes to classify these micro-flats as separate dwellings requiring their own council tax banding. Seeing as they are generally only rented to benefit claimants that means that the council receives no net council tax on the entire set of flats, whereas as an HMO the landlord himself would have had to pay the full council tax in all cases where the house did not exclusively contain students.

    Reply

Comment Policy: I would dearly love to hear your thoughts. However I ask that you please only use your real name and keep your comments focused on the issues raised by this article. If you want to contact me privately you can do so by sending me a message directly. My contact details are included on this site. Spam, or abusive comments will be deleted

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

What we are writing about

Investigative journalism telling the real story of contemporary London. In particular we are interested in:

Planning, development and affordable housing

Estate Regeneration and compulsory purchase

Bad practice and fraud in the property and development industry

But any stories which give an insight into how the economy and places of London are changing are welcome. If you have a story you are interested in please connect with us using the buttons below.

About Me

George TurnerGeorge Turner - an investigative journalist digging the dirt on London's property and development industry Read More

Archives

  • May 2018
  • March 2018
  • February 2018
  • July 2017
  • April 2017
  • March 2017
  • February 2017
  • January 2017
  • December 2016
  • November 2016
  • October 2016
  • September 2016
  • August 2016
  • July 2016
  • June 2016
  • May 2016
  • April 2016
  • March 2016
  • February 2016
  • December 2015

Recent Comments

  • John on Lockdown Landlords Acquitted
  • Concerned Citizens (@dequacivis) on The Battersea Power Station affordable housing scandal: How Wandsworth Gave away over 1000 affordable homes to a failing developer
  • HCLG Report Highlights ‘Lockdown’ as a significant problem – Hanworth.org on Lockdown landlord convicted for breaches in Planning Act
  • Hussain on The Housing Crisis
  • Ben Jamin' on The Housing Crisis

Tags

8 Albert Embankment Affordable Housing BNP Paribas Camden Canary Wharf Canary Wharf Group Canon A1 caroline pidgeon Compulsory Purchase Daylight DCLG Development development professionals Estate Regeneration Foreign Ownership GLA Planning Committee Heygate Isle of Dogs King's College Knight Frank Lambeth LFEPA Mayor of London Neighbourhood planning Offshore Planning Protest Quod RIBA RICS RTPI Sadiq Khan Savills Shell Shell Centre sian berry South Bank Spinwatch Sue Foster surveyors Viability Viability Consultants Wandsworth Westminster Wood Wharf

Recent Comments

  • John on Lockdown Landlords Acquitted
  • Concerned Citizens (@dequacivis) on The Battersea Power Station affordable housing scandal: How Wandsworth Gave away over 1000 affordable homes to a failing developer
  • HCLG Report Highlights ‘Lockdown’ as a significant problem – Hanworth.org on Lockdown landlord convicted for breaches in Planning Act
  • Hussain on The Housing Crisis
  • Ben Jamin' on The Housing Crisis

Newsletter

Subscribe to my newsletter

Never miss a story. I will never pass on your details and will email you no more than once a week.

Please wait...

Thank you for subscribing

Copyright © 2021 George Turner · Website powered by WordPress using the Genesis Framework · Log in